Pie's GALORE

Just like mom's

The best pie (and pie crust!) you've ever had!

We try to provide the best product we possibly can, buying local fruit and other ingredients when they are available. It is our goal to recreate memories of food experiences and nostalgic emotions, for example: making a pie that reminds them of one their grandma or mom made them.

We try to provide the best product we possibly can, buying local fruit and other ingredients when they are available. It is our goal to recreate memories of food experiences and nostalgic emotions, for example: making a pie that reminds them of one their grandma or mom made them.

PIES

Over 65 pie flavors to choose from!

events & gatherings

For weddings and special events.

fresh goodies

Buns - Cookies - and More!

want to taste and see?
come visit!

Visit us at ROOTS MARKET on Tuesdays!

Handmade. Baked with love. Just like Mom's.

from Scratch

with love

For everyone

Why I began making pies

Welcome to Pies Galore & More in Mount Joy, Pa. We are a local, hometown bakery, offering delicious made-to-order specialty pies and baked goods. All items are made by hand, from scratch, with the freshest ingredients and the careful attention of local baker, Donna Alexander.

AND WE LOVE MAKING YOU SMILE!

pies-galore-002
pies-galore-000
pies-galore-005
you asked - we answered!

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS​

Yes, we make everything, including the pie pastry
We make over 65 different pies, including meat pies and quiche.
Yes, we do make pies for weddings.
Yes, we take orders; please give us a 48 hour notice.

“Pies Galore makes the best pies ever, with pie crust that is light and flaky, just the way it should be.”

Mike Stuart

5-star yelp

“Best. Pie. Ever.

Hands down.”

Justin Rule

5-star Google

“Donna must be magic – because her pies and baked goods are soooo good!”

Sarah Wright

5-star Facebook

Serving Lancaster & beyond

OUR COMMITMENT IS TO EXCELLENT BAKING